Versions Compared

Old Version 10

changes.mady.by.user Stephen Lawrence

Saved on

compared with

New Version 11

changes.mady.by.user Stephen Lawrence

Saved on

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Comment: minor text cleanup

...

  • Tieto: AUTOSAR analysis ongoing.  Need tooling soon.  
  • VSC tooling seems held up by something.  End of this week consider if we should launch plan B.  Talk to Magnus about it.

    VSC:
  • Piotr: Has ASN.1 been considered as a definition language?  (it could be an alternative to protobuf?) 
    • ... the compilers are often able to generate a compact binary format
    • ... likely less availability of open-source tools.  There should be some however.
  • Gunnar: For VSS I think it's "overkill" since VSS has very simple datatypes but for VSC and arbitrarily complex data definitions, maybe
  • Gunnar: FYI: OpenAPI and AsyncAPI have however come up as potential reuse or inspiration for VSC definition.  Franca IDL is still a strong basis however.
    OpenAPI is only REST-focused and AsyncAPI seems to describe primarily a pub/sub direction.  

    VSS
  • Stephen:  I was recently reading about GraphQL Federation that allows seperation of concerns and for domain teams to create parts of the data graph that are then federated into a whole. The seperation of concerns resonated with in-vehicle engineering where you have for example services with very different safety and security requirements. Could this help us?

...