Page History

...

• Which topic in the matrix will you provide resources to?
• Which topics are still missing?
• Are the already existing proposed (sub) projects appropriate for you?
  • Is there any hindrance for you to participate in those existing proposed projects (GENIVI, W3C participation)
• Which (new) sub-project meeting will your company start and lead?
• Which parts (sub-trees in the hierarchy) of the standard data / services catalog will you provide input to?
• Which technologies would you like to propose in the "agreed-upon" technology stack?
• How can we start discussing your internal structure (organizational/technical) to understand how the CVII best supports it?  
  • E.g.:  Which standards do you use today?
  •         Where is it realistic to introduce the new standards?
  •         Where (in your particular system) shall there be translation between legacy/proprietary and the new standards?
• Will your company further support the development of these types of activities by joining GENIVI and/or W3C?

...

Partial Reply RB GmbH (Bosch)

• Which topic in the matrix will you provide resources to?

  CATALOG	Develop main Standard Data Catalog
  (META)MODEL	Define standard Data model Rule Set / meta-model
  ALIGNMENT	Align with SENSORIS

• Which topics are still missing?
  • Not completely "missing", but "Services/RPC" are an important point, Currently (VSC) almost nothing, and not clear how it will "tie into" VSS without reinventing the wheel
    • Gunnar: Good point.  There are already discussions (in VSS call and RPC/VSC meeting) and some proposed strategy for this.  But I think it's important enough to add, so I created a line in the table.
  • In terms of ARA:: Com there are two perfectly matching mechanisms => Events and Methods => IMHO VSS is the perfect base for that discussion
    • Gunnar: +1.  To each company: please help us identify who (involved in AUTOSAR) can be part of driving that discussion.
  • Kind of Kind of reference implementation (partly covered by kuksa.val) but whole stack is missingval) but whole stack is missing
    • Gunnar:  The key is to identify which parts are promoted as either "reference" or simply "good" implementation of each technology.  What already exists vs. what is missing from a complete stack ought to be described (use a diagram), and then broken down into development project for the missing parts.
  • Would a CVI Dev Kit help?
    • Gunnar: One way we often do this is develop the components, then produce a demo that integrates them all.  The demo should be placed in a combined repository (using appropriate technology such as references/git-submodules etc.)  
    • But if we can create a "dev kit" (with components, and documentations for how to integrate them) this is even more flexible.  
    Would a CVI Dev Kit help?
• Are the already existing proposed (sub) projects appropriate for you?
  • VSS development project, W3C VISSv2
    
    • Working on VSS standard
    • Working on, invite participation in C++ kuksa.val VISS server https://github.com/eclipse/kuksa.val , hopefully VISSv2 in future
  • Is there any hindrance for you to participate in those existing proposed projects (GENIVI, W3C participation)
    • not a W3C member yet
• Which technologies would you like to propose in the "agreed-upon" technology stack?
  • a more "binary" representation of requests in transport protocols instead of JSON (e.g CBOR, protobuf...)
    • Gunnar: +1.  This is a clear technology stack subproject.
  • best practice how to extend/widen/leverage VSS data model to a fully semantic digital twin for knowledge engineering in backend
  • DDS, MQTT, D-BUS, DAPR.IO, ...
    • Gunnar: Indeed these are additional  useful technologies.  Other stakeholders may also give their view on priorities.

...

 [ ] Ted Guild Can you help out to link to W3C meeting information.  In particular I could only write "bi-weekly" but that does not specify exactly when.  A link to wiki or mailing list where invites are sent, will help.

...

• Scope does not include to define who has access data
• Might be impacted by work by The Automotive Alliance?